Girth hands down everytime 😎👍

Long and thin goes right in, but short and thick does the trick...

Definitely girth, and then right after that a really heavy cummer.

Girth every time. Nothing as good as a thick cock in my hand.

Well I'm 8 3/8 long but I've always thought I was thin,so I bought a pump and I reach the end of the pump no problem. However the good thing is after pumping I have gained a little girth now. It doesn't really show that much unless I'm erect so just to maintain I pump once or twice a week now. People might think pumps are bs but they do work but you must be careful so not to damage nerves. If anyone doubts that pumps work just check out Hillcrest swimwear. She makes custom swimsuits and underwear for naturally endowed guys as well as pumpers. Some guys who have sent her pics of them in her suits are huge. Some hang below their knees and their cocks are as big around as a softball,some even bigger.

Long and thin goes right in, but short and thick does the trick...

Between 4 to 5 inches in length or girth. I've only have sucked 4 different cocks and they all fell in this range. I would think larger is harder to do. But I also think average size or smaller in both length and girth are the most appealing to look at too

When I'm sucking a cock, I prefer "smaller than average" in both length and girth.

My fuckbuddy has a nice thick cock, and the sex with him is always amazing. I've had slimmer cocks, but they've not been enjoyable. Although those guys were lacking in length too, and were 2 pump chumps.

i think girth or length does not mater to me

I always wonder. I'm long but pretty thin

Girth, girth, girth! No point in hitting the bottom of the barrel if you don't scuff up the sides too. Give me a 7x6 cock over a 9x5 one any day. Anything over 6 inches in circumference is pure heaven!

Girth

Both

For me, it's pussy that's important.

I think girth

Length is definitely more important when it comes to sucking. A decent length can make up for a thin dick but girth can't really make up for a dick that's too short.

Also there's no such thing as too long because if you can't take the whole thing you can always stroke and suck at the same time. But there definitely is such a thing as too thick - you just can't fit much of it in.

the whole package, length and girth are great if the dude is a great fuck, its more about the guy and how he fucks and if he's a total sexual package, no point having a big cock if you blow in 5 minutes and fall asleep *lix*

Which is more important for great sex? A pussy, of course, any pussy will do, preferably a willing one.