Want a bigger penis?
Enlarge it At Home
Using Just Your Hands!
Become an expert in
pussy licking!
She'll Beg You For More!
Tired of ads
on this site?
Get Paid For
Using Social Sites!

I'll honestly comment of your cock-pictures

Discussion Forum on Show Your Dick

Page #21

Pages:  #1... #16   #17   #18   #19   #20   #21   #22   #23   #24   #25  
Started by #188764 [Ignore] 30,Jan,12 06:05
A couple other guys have posts like this, but since none are on the first page I'll dive in with my own.

I consider myself a good judge of cock-appeal (check out my "favorites" album), so post one or more of yours here, and I'll give you my honest opinion of your cock and the photo quality.


Edit: Pissed about the typo in the subject line ("of" should be "on"); can't correct it.
New Comment       Rating: 3  


Comments:
By #234920 18,Feb,12 09:35
what a great forum...PLEASE GIVE ME YOUR HONEST OPINION OF MINE...Im keen to know
By #188764 18,Feb,12 09:45
I'll judge the pics in the 2nd and 3rd rows of your album.

Cock: Very attractive and well-proportioned; nice veining along the shaft; powerful erection; bonus for shaved hair. Grade: A+

Composition: Good lighting, focus, and angles of view; could be cropped a bit tighter. Grade: A
By #234920 18,Feb,12 09:56
never had such a thorough description, thanks. how about the size though, length, width etc. on a scale of 1-10 1being tiny and 10 being ridiculas monster. honestly where am i for lenght and girth and shape, if u dont mind letting me know
By #188764 18,Feb,12 10:50
I'd give it an 8.5 on the size-o-meter, both length and girth.

I don't grade for size (though you'll see that I sometimes comment on it) because I can judge a cock of ANY size to be an A+ if it's esthetically pleasing. The beauty of a cock isn't in how massive it is... though that might well contribute to its erotic appeal. As it happens, I have warm spot in my heart for smaller-sized cocks (perhaps because mine is small).


By #201367 16,Feb,12 23:23
Can you rate mine?
By #188764 18,Feb,12 07:57
Cock: Nicely proportioned; very attractive head; shaft is good but could be a bit smoother; bonus for trimmed hair. Grade: A

Composition: Most of your pics have outstanding lighting, focus, angle of view, and cropping. Good job! Grade: A+
By #201367 18,Feb,12 09:19
Thanks so much for the rating!


By #215748 18,Feb,12 07:30
[deleted image]
my head
[deleted image]
my shaft
[deleted image]
my shot
By #188764 18,Feb,12 09:05
Cock: Well proportioned and attractive; slight curve in the shaft detracts a bit, as does the coloration of the head. Grade: A-

Composition: Very good lighting and focus; nice variety of angles; artistic cum-shot. Grade: A+


By #222595 17,Feb,12 12:17
By #188764 18,Feb,12 08:19
Cock: Pleasing proportions, with attractive shaft and head; the upward curve emphasizes the impressively strong erection; bonus for shaved/trimmed hair, but deduction because you left it bushy at the sides. Grade: A/A+

Composition: Excellent angle of view; good lighting and focus; could be cropped a little tighter. Grade: A


By #4812 17,Feb,12 09:25
HI,HOW ABOUT MINE,I HAVE ALMOST 800 PICTURES,CHECK THEM OUT AND TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK
By #188764 18,Feb,12 08:13
Impressive collection!

Cock: Very pleasing proportions; shaft is a good medium-size and attractive; the head is perfect; bonus for shaved hair. Grade: A+

Composition: Not all are of equal quality, but your best ones are flawless in lighting, focus, angle of view, and cropping. A+


By #214830 17,Feb,12 08:14
Okay took 5 new ones can I have a regrade please
By #188764 18,Feb,12 08:06
MUCH better composition on the new ones!


By #217691 17,Feb,12 01:51
[deleted image] ...it's what God/Allah/Budda/Whomever gave me; be kind, .
By #188764 18,Feb,12 08:03
Cock: Good proportions in the smaller-than-average category; reasonably attractive head; bonus for shaved hair; extra bonus because I like small cocks; deduction for less-than-full erection. Grade: A-

Composition: The two side-views are good in their lighting, angle and cropping... ok in their focus; backgrounds detract. Grade: B+


By #232009 16,Feb,12 22:43
and mine
By #188764 18,Feb,12 07:52
Cock: A good example of a small-than-average cock; pleasing proportions; reasonably attractive head; bonus for trimmed hair; deduction for composition. Grade: B+

Composition: Lighting and focus are weak; angle of view not the best (try a side-view); prop is gimmicky. Grade: C

I'm a fan of small cocks, so post some more (better) pics.


By #114463 16,Feb,12 23:01
Sorry, here is the picture what do you think

[deleted image]
By #188764 18,Feb,12 07:46
That's the one I commented on! Very nice!


By #114463 16,Feb,12 22:38
/v6daxma5ie2epic.html

me me .gif'>
By #188764 18,Feb,12 07:46
Can't get your link to show. I'll comment on your best - the last pic on the 8th row of your album.

Cock: Classically attractive; beautiful shaft and head that combine in excellent proportions. Grade: A+

Composition: Lighting, focus, angle of view, and cropping are all quite good. Grade: A+


By #56944 16,Feb,12 06:47
/1eemdc6yljnipic.html
By #188764 18,Feb,12 07:41
Your link doesn't work, so I'll comment on the third pic in your album.

Cock: A winner in the longer-than-average category; excellent proportions of shaft to head, with both being exceptionally attractive; bonus for close-trimmed hair. Grade: A++

Composition: Lighting, focus, angle of view, and cropping are all first-rate. Grade: A+


By #211106 16,Feb,12 05:40
well what do u think /uuh4ahsigz2cpic.html
By #188764 18,Feb,12 07:35
Cock: A classically proportioned cock; thick, smooth shaft; very attractive head. Grade: A

Composition: Good angle of view and nicely cropped, but the lighting and focus could be better. Grade: A-


By #231712 16,Feb,12 05:24
/image/i6uqt1fiq044_2605492532.jpg
By #188764 16,Feb,12 05:35
Couldn't view the link for some reason. I'll go with the second of the pics in your album.

Cock: Impressive shaft, thick and smooth; attractive and proportional head, with a nice ridge; deduction for no erection (take some pics just like that, but fully erect). Grade: A

Composition: Very good (but not perfect) lighting and focus; excellent angle of view and cropping. Grade: A


By #232650 15,Feb,12 18:18
Take a look at mine when you get a chance and let me know what you think.
By #188764 16,Feb,12 05:27
Sorry, but focus and view issues make it difficult to see what your cock really looks like.


By #215020 15,Feb,12 11:39
What do you think about my cock?
[deleted image]
[deleted image]
[deleted image]
By #188764 16,Feb,12 05:25
Cock: Thick, manly, but nicely smooth; an attractive proportional head; good erection; an effective fucking machine; bonus for trimmed hair. Grade: A+

Composition: Good lighting, focus, and angle of view. Grade: A


By #124157 15,Feb,12 11:20
Please chech ut mine
By #188764 16,Feb,12 05:18
Cock: Attractive smaller-than-average shaft; difficult to grade the head; composition detracts. Grade: B

Composition: None of the pics show your cock effectively (I'm not a fan of foreskin covering the head of an erection); lighting is ok, but focus is an issue. I'd like to see a well-focused, hands-off, side-view of a full erection with the foreskin pulled back. Grade: C+


By #214830 15,Feb,12 07:57
Hey can't get my pic to uupload please could you check out my page and tell me what you think
By #188764 16,Feb,12 05:12
Cock: Attractive smooth shaft; proportional head; firm erection in some pics. Grade: A

Composition: Ack! I get vertigo looking at your album! The pictures are mostly upside-down or sideways, and none show your cock effectively. Lighting and focus are good on some. Grade: C-


By #228697 14,Feb,12 13:57
what about me
By #188764 15,Feb,12 06:38
Cock: A nicely shaped and proportional smaller-than-average cock; the best view is in the 3rd-from-last, which shows it provocatively boyish; deduction for not showing a free-standing erection; bonus for shaved hair. Grade: A-

Composition: Lighting and/or focus are issues in several of the pics; none show your cock at its best (side view, fully erect, fully visible). Grade: B+


By #52072 14,Feb,12 06:42
wat abt mine balt?
By #188764 15,Feb,12 06:29
Cock: Nice smooth smaller-than-average shaft; head is proportional, but the shape is a bit "off" and the coloration is an issue (though perhaps I'm being ethno-centric); bonus for trimmed/shaved hair. Grade: B

Composition: A very mixed bag; some have good lighting and focus, but some are pretty bad (need to self-edit); None have an angle of view that shows you to best effect. Grade: C+


By #184374 14,Feb,12 02:03
[deleted image]
[deleted image]
[deleted image]
By #188764 15,Feb,12 06:20
Cock: Very virile and fully-erect shaft; attractive head, but not as wide as the ideal; bonus for trimmed hair. Grade: A

Composition: Great lighting, focus, and angle of view on the first two; the third strives to be artistic, but doesn't show your cock nearly as well. Cumulative grade: A-


By #230703 13,Feb,12 22:48
cant figure out ho wto post a pic. would you mind rating me?
By #188764 15,Feb,12 06:15
Cock: Attractive shaft; head has a nice width and a prominent ridge, but a bit too short. Grade: A-

Composition: Good lighting and focus; ok angle of view. Grade: A


By #227467 13,Feb,12 17:06
here's s new one for your honest opinion. (partial erection)

[deleted image]
By #188764 15,Feb,12 06:09
Cock: Massively thick shaft (a bit TOO thick for esthetics, but great for fucking); proportional head; slight deduction for less-than-full erection. Grade: A-


Composition: Great lighting and angle of view; good focus. Grade: A


By #211761 13,Feb,12 15:44
what about mine?

[deleted image]

[deleted image]

[deleted image]
By #188764 13,Feb,12 16:30
Cock: Nicely-shaped shaft, with a firm erection; I like to see the head, so the foreskin is a hindrance to judging (though no doubt a turn-on for foreskin lovers). Grade: A-

Composition: Good lighting and focus on the first two; not on the third; good angles of view in the first two; third should be cropped tighter. Cumulative Grade: A-


By #233619 13,Feb,12 09:10
[deleted image]
By #188764 13,Feb,12 13:30
Cock: Nice size shaft; head lacks a prominent ridge; composition detracts. Grade: B+

Composition: Lighting, focus, and angle of view all fall short... but still an ok pic. Grade: B-


New Comment   Go to top

Pages:  #1... #16   #17   #18   #19   #20   #21   #22   #23   #24   #25  



Show your Genitals